So what I think we are all getting out of this is that finishing your enemies if you have won is wicked but having this option is a double edged sword because they can finish you too.
Mattk50 wrote:as long as capturing is the better, more profitable option, then you have some motivation to not just kill everything, same with NPCs.
Mattk50 is right. As long as making them your slaves or delivering bandits to the police has a more reasonable option, then the killing and the capturing is balanced.
1337 wrote:It also makes the game more interesting in my opinion: you start asking yourself "is it worth taking the risk of attacking that group" and so on and if you happen to lose a battle and lose some guys, you will seek revenge more actively, mourning over the loss of a samurai you named personally and trained with love.
1337 then stated that it makes the player think more about the choices they make. Like if they want to risk their party. Risk the "samurai you named personally and trained with love" and with saying that, revenge would come into play. Trying to avenge your fallen comrades would make the game a much more personal experience.
Blxz wrote:When it is within reason then, yes! That's the whole reason I started that thread a while back. But as someone else said, random murder is not fun gameplay or all that believable in most cases. So, can you find a good reason to have this? Might tie into the whole 'reputation' thing that someone in another thread was talking about.
Then Blxz gave another reason, so it would tie into the reputation system. He then stated that if you kill people, people are more likely to kill you because of your bad reputation. Say you killed some of the Knights who wear yellow (The Empire I believe), the Blue knights who fight them would like you a lot more and maybe even give you rewards, or help you out when your in a tight spot some time.
1337 wrote:If you are a true Samurai and you lose a fight, you either die in battle or commit seppuku

And then 1337 sarcastically stated that you should be able to perform an honorable suicide
