Tried the Game and heres my feedback

Post Reply
benpowell987
Posts: 78
Joined: Wed Sep 05, 2012 1:12 pm

Wed Sep 05, 2012 2:13 pm

I recently saw this game on steam greenlight, and me being an RPG and an RTS fan, I immidiately got the demo version. I understood fully that this game is just in it's alpha development, and that's s'all cool. I'm going to split the diffrent aspects into the game into a neatly compiled list now, s'ok?

Camera - I quite enjoyed the camera angles and movement, the fact that it presents a challange, but one that is not that hard, it presents a challange in combat, and the hybrid movement between WASD and the mouse scroll button, is quite fun too... My only complaint is movement inbetween charactors, I'm not sure if it is on the top ( or bottom ) of your to do list, but jumping inbetween charactors that are far apart, rather i'm not complaining, but just a thing to think on.

Details - I fully understand that the art work is not a massive problem on your list at the present moment, But at this stage in development, I quite enjoyed the graphics, the vast open desert and the towns, One thing that put's me off is the ability to go into the clear of the game, meaning you can zoom under the game area, and see through quite alot of the mountains.. other than that, Kudos to chris on this, No complaints, no complaints. although there seems to be a bug/and or missing detail, on masks, just a large red X appears in it's place in the inventory screen ( it is quite off putting.. )

Combat - The combat poses quite a large challange, forcing the players into a stalemate diciding to go on a suicide attack on a large group of hungry bandits, or enploy tactics and use your best friends ''the meatbags'' ( the guards at your nearest town ). The fact that all the enemy's pose a large overpoweredness until day two of gameplay, presents a satisfying challange, finally knowing that your group of ten can take on one Sand Ninja journeyman is quite a reward indeed.

RTS - Stated that you are currently working as hard as possible on this side of the game, I quite enjoyed the content that the game has to offer at the moment, I am going to absulutely love more buildings, the factions, and the research, although I'm not sure what you'd be researching, Possible trade alliances with other settlements? Diffrent abilities to travel? ( such as large hot air ballons or ''Zepelines'' that are preset to travel inbetween settlements, too which you can just walk streight on ) Diffrent armour types? and possible more building architypes? Other than that, when factions are introduced fully, I do think, that just reading in the news / updater that will be enough for the word ''mmmmh'' even a ''OH GOD YES, YES, AND YES!''

RPG - I quite enjoy in house roleplaying, one where I where I I create a storyline between charactors, But in game the aspects of Roleplay that are there, is quite satisfactory for the present moment, meaning the conversations between NPC's and Player charactor's is too a level it should be for the moment, but I would like to ask a guard about directions or so forth... The thing that is a MUST for any RPG game, even if it is a hybrid with something else is a background lore...I would be quite oblidged to offer my hand in the creation of this, But will note it later..

Architecture - I belive that the repeatedly used buildings tend to spoil the game, But it is livable with, due too the fact that again, it is still in alpha, and it appears that there are more buildings to come, Soo, no complaints here... again :mrgreen:

I did go and buy the game the very next day soo... :lol:

Bugs -

- North of black scratch there are hills that seem passable but you get stuck on an invisable wall at some point, will update with a screenshot of its location soon...

- The ability to go through any hills with your camera, ( not a bug, but very off putting... :( )

- several crashes at cirtain Containers within shops, ( will update with a list of which soon )

- several more, updating as I play.

- Not quite sure if this is a visual bug, or it's not been inplemented yet: the fact that when building structures, the wooden scaffolding doesn't appear such as shown in the screenshots on the newsfeed.

Posted Detailed bug thread Here: http://www.lofigames.com/phpBB3/viewtop ... f=9&t=1423

Suggestions -

- More architecture, such as bandit outposts, and what not

- More hostiles from the start, somewhat abit less OP, maybe demote hungry bandits, to a player killable from the off, and introduce nomad's, as there are, from my counting, about five types of enemy's, Hardly enough :( .

- As you introduce the chemist / hospital, add something like, weapons too which are poisonable, would be quite fun to paralzye an enemy before taking him to your hide out, and using him as a decoration ( because I am harsh like that )

- Would love to be able to hover over signs aswell , E.G pub signs and have there own veried name pop up, like you would right clicking a Bandit or somin',

- More hired swords, and maybe an ability to change names whilst out of charactor creation screen.. ( as sometimes, I know I'm not the only one whom does this, and it is quite Roleplayingly ruinable... :ugeek: if yer'get me'drift ) As sometimes I completely blank out, edit the charactors appearance, and forget too change the name.

- Not too sure if it will be inplemented but I've seen it somewhere I think... WALLS! ability to create your own walls for your citadel... I will name it the spire, and it will be my spir-... urhm.... Yes, walls..




I am currently offering my survices as a volenteer to write up a Background lore for each army, for each town, and for the game itself, if chris would like to give me a bell ( an inbox ) with what he wants for all types of that, As I am currently not sure if this game is a eastern wasteland? eastern steampunk hybrid, or wha', So if you want me too help you with this, I would love too know what you are up too..

EDIT: I do apologise for the rather.. large harry potter book i've just wrote, so aye, But as I Play the list of suggestions, and bugs will get rather... stretched.. so aye... And the grammer & spelling errors will be fixed as soon as I get back from the NEC, ( just woke up, and I am quite.... yer'know.. tired, and drinking relentless :ugeek: )
Last edited by benpowell987 on Wed Sep 05, 2012 9:29 pm, edited 2 times in total.
It's Pi e Day Pi e Day.
Gotta'get down on Pi e day.

User avatar
djfabiokk
Posts: 226
Joined: Mon Sep 03, 2012 4:29 am
Location: Venezuela.

Wed Sep 05, 2012 2:22 pm

Nice wall of text you got there, just joking.

I dont think the research things its going to involve hot air ballons. The research its just going to be to get better weapons, maybe upgrade them, who knows, or get better buildings, maybe increase the profit from the building ( i think this will be added ) and other things.

For the hat and the red X, well that is not a bug, its just that there is no texture because there was no artist, now chris hired one and he made the male char a little bit more cool, so i think they will need to edit all the armor, maybe they will finish the hat textures.

User avatar
toaster Assassin
Posts: 1186
Joined: Thu Sep 29, 2011 6:27 am
Location: Sitting at the front desk of the universe and holding the key to unlock your mind.

Wed Sep 05, 2012 2:23 pm

I was the one who moved your thread, Because really there is no point to clutter the forum with topics of a repeat name, perhaps it is wiser to have a different name.-Toaster Assassin :|
A voice in your computer's memory that refuses to go away. Now with 15% more (side notes!)

Semper fidelis amplus crustulum!
Image
Kenshi forum rules: (We will assume that you have read this).

benpowell987
Posts: 78
Joined: Wed Sep 05, 2012 1:12 pm

Wed Sep 05, 2012 2:24 pm

Aye, I wasnt entirely sure of that at the moment soo, I have listed it as a bug, DJFA cheers for the feedback :D

And I do apologise, it was an agressive tactics to undermind the writer of the other one but aye, i've changed the name for fun... cheers for owning up too the move, love yer'toastie 8-)
It's Pi e Day Pi e Day.
Gotta'get down on Pi e day.

User avatar
toaster Assassin
Posts: 1186
Joined: Thu Sep 29, 2011 6:27 am
Location: Sitting at the front desk of the universe and holding the key to unlock your mind.

Wed Sep 05, 2012 2:26 pm

Its all good my friend, however just change the whole name, not just one word.


Edit: reason being, we must prevent a tactical geek cynical post war.
A voice in your computer's memory that refuses to go away. Now with 15% more (side notes!)

Semper fidelis amplus crustulum!
Image
Kenshi forum rules: (We will assume that you have read this).

benpowell987
Posts: 78
Joined: Wed Sep 05, 2012 1:12 pm

Wed Sep 05, 2012 2:32 pm

Thats the fun part of being a keyboard warrior :( - toaster
It's Pi e Day Pi e Day.
Gotta'get down on Pi e day.

User avatar
toaster Assassin
Posts: 1186
Joined: Thu Sep 29, 2011 6:27 am
Location: Sitting at the front desk of the universe and holding the key to unlock your mind.

Wed Sep 05, 2012 2:35 pm

Yeah, but it eventually becomes out of hand. Then threads become locked (Its happened before)




Edit: This is a rather lax forum so its all good, just be careful not to piss other people off.
A voice in your computer's memory that refuses to go away. Now with 15% more (side notes!)

Semper fidelis amplus crustulum!
Image
Kenshi forum rules: (We will assume that you have read this).

User avatar
Diruk
Posts: 124
Joined: Mon Sep 03, 2012 6:19 am
Location: 41st Millennium

Wed Sep 05, 2012 3:03 pm

toaster Assassin wrote:Yeah, but it eventually becomes out of hand. Then threads become locked (Its happened before)




Edit: This is a rather lax forum so its all good, just be careful not to piss other people off.
The Toaster Protects. (just had to say that)
Derp Derp Derpa!

benpowell987
Posts: 78
Joined: Wed Sep 05, 2012 1:12 pm

Wed Sep 05, 2012 9:30 pm

Edited:

Added more suggestions, and put something about architecture.
It's Pi e Day Pi e Day.
Gotta'get down on Pi e day.

Post Reply
  • Information
  • Who is online

    Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 12 guests